Research proposal writer

CHAPTER TWO

LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1 Introduction

This chapter discusses what various scholars have written about the level of tax education about vat conducted, the determinants of vat performance and policies for improving the performance of vat in Uganda.

2.2 LEVEL OF TAX EDUCATION ABOUT VAT CONDUCTED

The origins of the VAT can be traced back to the writings of a German economist F Von Siemens, who proposed the VAT in 1918 as a substitute for the then newly established German turnover tax. The development of these proposals into the introduction of a VAT in a state is credited to Maurice Faure and Carl Shoup who were responsible with the introduction in France in 1954 of the Taxe sur la Valeur Adjoutee.1 Since then over 100 countries have introduced some form of VAT –the only OECD country not to have done so is the United States.

VATs have become the most common type of consumption tax for a variety of reasons. Unlike income taxes, VATs do not distort consumption-savings/investment decisions.2 Because sellers can claim a credit for VAT paid on their inputs, there is no cascading of taxes as can occur with other consumption taxes. The tax is often regarded as “self-policing” as it is imposed on every transaction throughout the production process reducing revenue losses should one party fail to collect VAT. It is also neutral between the domestic production and imported goods when compared to an import tariff.3 It has been widely recognised that a well designed VAT can raise significant amounts of revenue on a stable and sustainable basis and the decision to introduce a VAT has often been made for these reasons.

A commonly cited disadvantage of VATs is that they can be regressive in nature being a problem which can arise with most types of indirect tax. A single rate VAT applied to the broadest possible base becomes essentially a proportional tax on consumption and therefore regressive.5 Often to address this problem of regressivity, multiple rates of VAT are offered along with a range of exemptions even though such provisions have a negative impact on the effectiveness and efficiency of VAT.

Regressivity is usually a greater issue for developing countries where a large proportion of the population lives in poverty. For this reason, many developing countries have adopted multiple VAT rates with the lower rates applying to necessities such as food and utilities as well as exempting a wide range of goods and services to promote greater progressivity.7 Empirical studies into VAT adopted in developing countries have shown that such measures do address the problems of regressivity and make the tax more progressive.

The introduction of a VAT in a developing country has its own challenges.9 They are usually introduced in developing countries as part of an economic liberalisation programme involving reductions in tariffs often at the recommendation of international advisory bodies such as the IMF or World Bank. In order to maintain adequate tax revenues, many developing countries have found it necessary to retain excise taxes to offset revenue losses from tariff reductions and also for social purposes. This has resulted in the VAT being an additional tax impost rather than a replacement for existing taxes leading to greater complexity for businesses.

Obtaining compliance with VAT laws in a developing country can be a challenge especially where there is a large informal sector.10 In most developing countries the majority of VAT collected is from imports with the remainder collected from a few large taxpayers

2.2  Determinants of VAT performance

Osoro (1993) examined the revenue productivity implications of tax reforms in Tanzania. In the study, the tax buoyancy was estimated using double log form equation (2) and tax revenue elasticity using the proportional adjustment method (equation 4). The argument for the use of proportional method was that a series of discretionary changes had taken place during the sample period, 1979 to 1989, making the use of dummy variable technique impossible to apply (Osoro 1993). For the study period, the overall elasticity was 0.76 with buoyancy of 1.06. The study concluded that the tax reforms in Tanzania had failed to raise tax revenues. These results were attributed to the government granting numerous tax exemptions and poor tax administration.

Ariyo (1997) evaluated the productivity of the Nigerian tax system for the period 1970 – 1990. The aim was to devise a reasonable accurate estimation of Nigeria’s sustainable revenue profile. In the study, tax buoyancy and tax revenue elasticity were estimated using equation (4) and (5) respectively. The slope dummy equations were used for the oil boom and SAPs. It was found that on the overall, productivity level was satisfactory. However, the results indicated wide variations in the level of tax revenue by tax source. The were attributed to the laxity in administration of non-oil tax sources during the oil boom periods. Significant reduction in public expenditure and prudent management of financial resources were suggested as solutions to the fiscal deficit. The study further asserted that there was need to improve the tax information system to enhance the evaluation of its performance and facilitate adequate macro-economic planning and implementation (Ariyo, 1997:33)

Chipeta (1998) evaluated effects of tax reforms on tax yields in Malawi for the period 1970 to 1994. The results indicated buoyancy of 0.95 and an elasticity of 0.6. The study concluded that the tax bases had grown less rapidly than GDP. Kusi (1998) studied tax reform and revenue productivity of Ghana for the period 1970 to 1993. Results showed a pre-reform buoyancy of 0.72 and elasticity of 0.71 for the period 1970 to 1982. The period after reform, 1983 to 1993, showed increased buoyancy of 1.29 and elasticity of 1.22. The study concluded that the reforms had contributed significantly to tax revenue productivity from 1983 to 1993.

Milambo (2001) used the Divisia Index method to study the revenue productivity of the Zambian tax structure for the period 1981 to 1999. The results showed elasticity of 1.15 and buoyancy of 2.0, which confirmed that tax reforms had improved the revenue productivity of the overall tax system. However, these results were not reliable because time trends were used as proxies for discretionary changes and this was the study’s major weakness.

In relation to Uganda , Ole (1975) estimated income elasticity of tax structure for the period 1962/63 to 1972/73. Tax revenue was regressed on income without adjusting for unusual observations. The results showed that the tax structure was income inelastic (0.81) for the period studied. The study recommended that the system required urgent reforms to improve its productivity. The results also implied that Uganda ’s tax structure was not buoyant and therefore the country would require foreign assistance to close the budget deficit.

Njoroge (1993) studied the revenue productivity of tax reforms in Uganda  for the period 1972/73 to 1990/91. Tax revenue was regressed on income after adjusting tax revenues for discretionary changes. The period of study was divided into two to make it easier to analyze the effects of tax reforms on revenues from various taxes. Income elasticity of total tax structure was found to be 0.67 for the period 1972 to 1981. This meant that the government received a decreasing share of rising GDP as tax revenues. The elasticity estimates for individual taxes were as follows: sales tax 0.6, import duties 0.45 and income tax 0.93. The buoyancy for the overall tax system for the same period was 1.19, implying that the tax system was quite buoyant.

In an attempt to highlight the trends in Uganda ’s tax ratios, tax effort indices and their implication for further tax reforms, Wawire (2003 and 2006) performed a regression of tax revenue on income. The estimated tax equation was used to compute tax effort indices by dividing the predicted with the actual figures. After examining the tax effort indices, the study concluded that the slowdown in economic growth had resulted in high levels of taxation that did not match delivery of public goods and services.

2.3 POLICIES FOR IMPROVING THE PERFORMANCE OF VAT

In this age of globalization, most developing countries want to become integrated with the international economy. However, they face significant challenges in this pursuit, including the need to increase tax revenues. Hence tax policy makers have to analyze the prevailing conditions in the country and determine the relevant mix of taxes that can raise sufficient revenue. Many developing countries, Uganda included, have increasingly begun to restructure their tax systems for this specific purpose. Despite numerous tax reforms that were intended to improve the economic and social situation by supporting infrastructure and increasing the quality of public goods provided by the government, the situation in Uganda remains fragile, and the country remains among the poorest in the world. Based on the current approved budget for the financial year 2005/2006, a widening budget deficit of 9.2% compared to the previous financial year of 8.6% was reporte, (MoF, 2007).

One of the most flexible ways to raise per capita incomes and to support increases in real GDP growth rates is through taxation. Taxation is a sovereign right of the state used to transfer resources from private to public use in order to achieve the economic and social goals, (Richard, 2009).

Governments can and do “commandeer resources” directly from the people. This method would be practicable only in war times, however, and would be rejected by the masses in peaceful times. Governments sometimes print the money they need to function,4 although it is recognized that this method drives inflation. Developing countries make heavy use of domestic and foreign borrowing, but this is not an adequate alternative to increasing tax revenues.5 The majority of the people in developing countries receive very low incomes, if any, from which the government cannot borrow. And it may not be constructive for a government to rely on foreign aid as there are many deleterious consequences flowing from aid dependency. Thus taxation emerges as one of the most effective domestic tools that governments have direct control over to develop the resources needed to meet their social, economic, and political goals.

Although Uganda’s revenue performance has improved remarkably in nominal terms from 1986 to 2006 as a result of these changes, it is still comparatively low and clearly does not meet Uganda’s needs as measured against optimal levels of public expenditure for the country.8 It is therefore accurate to conclude that the government must improve its tax policy to increase government revenues, but in a way that takes the realities of Uganda’s social and economic structures into consideration. The challenge of inefficient domestic revenue mobilization carries important policy implications for Uganda (among which are included bad public services and increased debt), because domestic revenue production has not improved significantly despite the many changes the government has made. While several piecemeal efforts have been implemented in Uganda, concrete ideas on how the overall tax system can be improved remain scarce.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *